Under the US Constitution, an accused enjoys the right to a speedy trial. US v. Danylo, 73 M.J. 183 (C.A.A.F. 2013). A service members 6th Amendment right to a speedy trial triggers upon the preferral of charges or pretrial restraint. That right is also codified in Article 10, UCMJ. Military courts look at 4 issues (so-called Barker/Moreno factors) when deciding whether the 6th Amendment right to a speedy trial has been violated: 1) The length of the delay; 2) The reason for the delay; 3) Whether the accused demanded a speedy trial; and, 4) Whether there was any prejudice to the accused (usually the loss of evidence due to the delay). Generally, the appellate courts do not view it as a speedy trial violation for the government to try co-accused before the accused – thereby creating a delay. There have been cases – in the law – where individuals have spent upwards of 350 days in pretrial confinement. Whether there has been a speedy trial violation is a question of law that the courts review de novo. US v. Arriaga, 70 M.J. 51 (C.A.A.F. 2010). Article 10 requires that once an accused is placed in pretrial confinement, immediate steps have to be taken to inform them of the charges, bring them to trial, or dismiss the charges. Article 10 provides a more demanding standard than the 6th Amendment. This is partly because the military does not have a bail system like the civilian sector. The right to a speedy trial can be waived for purposes of a guilty plea. Rule for Courts-Martial 707 also creates a right to a speedy trial. It basically requires that the accused be brought to trial within 120 days after pretrial confinement. Unfortunately, all sorts of government excuses can constitute good cause. Dismissal under R.C.M. 707 usually is without prejudice and allows the government to release the accused from confinement and refile charges.
Categories
Related Posts
-
What Is a Court-Martial?
Nov 01View ArticleCourt-Martial Meaning The court-martial meaning isn’t just a definition – it can be life-changing for any service member facing allegations under the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). In the simplest sense, a court-martial is a formal military criminal proceeding used to determine whether an accused committed an offense and, when appropriate, impose a lawful...
-
What Happens After You’re Accused of a Crime in the Military?
Sep 06View ArticleBeing accused of a crime in the military can be stressful and confusing. An accusation, however, is not the same thing as guilt. The military justice system includes multiple stages for reviewing allegations, gathering evidence, making charging decisions, and determining potential consequences. The exact timeline and outcome can vary significantly depending on the facts, the...
-
Can You Be Court-Martialed After a Civilian Trial? Double Jeopardy in the Military
Jan 22View ArticleWhen service members resolve a criminal matter in civilian court, many believe the legal process has fully concluded. In the military justice system, however, jurisdiction overlaps, sovereign authority differs, and constitutional protections operate under unique rules. One of the most misunderstood protections covers the double jeopardy military members face, particularly when they are forced to...